Loafers

Not sure about your size? Take our Fit Finder Quiz for a personalized size recommendation, or request a Fit Kit by mail (US Only). Prefer to try them on? Book an appointment in NYC, Chicago, or DC.

 
Need a quick reference? View Size Chart below.

Soft Penny Loafer

A gentle expression of timeless style—easy, elegant, and meant to be lived in.

In-stock: $268 | Made-to-order: $285

$335

In-stock: $268 | Made-to-order: $285

$335

In-stock: $268 | Made-to-order: $285

$335

The City Loafer

Designed for the rhythm of the city. Effortless, elevated, and endlessly wearable.

In-stock: $268 | Made-to-order: $285

$335

In-stock: $268 | Made-to-order: $285

$335

In-stock: $268 | Made-to-order: $285

$335

In-stock: $268 | Made-to-order: $285

$335

In-stock: $268 | Made-to-order: $285

$335

A great pair of women's loafers works harder than almost anything else in your closet, dressed up with tailored trousers or dressed down with denim.

 

Person wearing rolled-up jeans and white loafers against a beige background.

Ally's loafers are designed for women who refuse to choose between polish and comfort. Every pair is handcrafted with a supportive structure, a padded insole, and a leather or suede upper that moves with your foot. Available in US sizes 4-12, in half sizes and four widths: Narrow, Medium, Wide and Extra Wide.

Are Ally loafers comfortable enough to wear all day?

Yes. Every pair is built with a padded insole and built-in metatarsal and arch support, so your feet feel as good at 6pm as they did at 9am. No break-in period required.

How does Try Before You Buy work?

Fill out our trial box questionnaire to tell us about your fit and color preferences, enter your shipping information, and your trial box will be on its way. After you receive the box, you'll have 7 days to try them on around your house. Keep & pay for what you like and return the rest. Shipping time won't be counted towards your 7-day window, so you truly have 7 full days to make a decision.

To make sure your payment method is valid, a temporary hold will be placed on your card, which may appear as “pending” or “processing.” Please note we won't actually charge your card unless you decide to keep your shoes. If you choose to return your order within our 7-day trial, we’ll void the hold on your card. Depending on your bank this typically takes 1-2 business days.

Do Ally's women's loafers come in wide widths?

Every style is available in four widths, Narrow, Medium, Wide and Extra Wide, plus half sizes. Not sure where you fall? Take our free Fit Finder quiz or request a free measurement kit by mail.

 

What's the difference between the City Loafer and the Penny Loafer?

The City Loafer is made from a smooth, structured calfskin leather. The Soft Penny Loafer is our softest design, made in lambskin suede to hug your foot and move with you throughout the day. Read our full City vs Penny Loafer guide for the details.

Can I wear loafers to the office?

Yes. The City Loafer's clean lines and almond toe read professional with trousers or a structured dress, while the Penny Loafer works for a business casual office. Both share the same arch support underneath, so you're not trading comfort for polish either way.

Are leather loafers good for wide feet or bunions?

Yes. The wide and extra-wide options expand at the toe box while keeping the midfoot and heel snug, so the extra room sits exactly where a bunion needs it. Read more in our guide to shoes for wide feet.

What is the return and exchange policy?

Full-price unworn loafers are eligible for free exchanges and returns within 14 days of delivery for US orders. Exchanges are always complimentary. If you prefer a refund, a $12.99 handling fee applies, waived if you opt for store credit instead. Full details on our returns and exchanges page.